Skip to content

Every hearing and ruling in order, plus hand-picked podcasts, documentaries and clippings.

Murder of Cara Knott

Also known as Cara Evelyn Knott · Craig Alan Peyer

San Diego · California · United States · 1986 · 2 court matters

Current status

Convicted 22 Jun 1988Sentenced 3 Aug 1988 to 25 years to life

Last update: 11 Jan 2012 →

Quick answers

What was the latest development?
11 Jan 2012: Parole denied for 15 years. Timeline entry

Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.

Cara Evelyn Knott, 20, of El Cajon, California, was a student at San Diego State University. On the night of 27 December 1986 she was killed while driving home from a visit to her boyfriend's house in Escondido. Her family searched for her overnight, and her body was found the next morning.

On 15 January 1987 Craig Alan Peyer, a California Highway Patrol officer who had been on duty that night, was arrested and charged with her murder. His first trial began on 4 January 1988 and ended in a mistrial on 25 February 1988 after the jury split 7–5. A second trial began on 18 April 1988, and on 22 June 1988 the jury convicted him of first-degree murder. He was sentenced to 25 years to life on 3 August 1988.

The Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction on 27 June 1990, and the California Supreme Court denied review on 10 October 1990.

Where

San Diego, California, United States

Key moments

  1. 1986Body of Cara Knott discovered
  2. 1987Craig Alan Peyer arrested and charged with murder
See full timeline ↓

Court record

2 court matters: the 1987 charges ended in a conviction; and the 1994 civil suit is pending.

Prosecution · 19871 docket

Convicted22 Jun 1988

Fourth District Court of Appeal affirms conviction · 27 Jun 1990

People of the State of California v. Craig Alan Peyer

San Diego Superior CourtCalifornia
Timeline entries in this matter (7)

Civil suit · 19941 docket

Pending

Knott v. State of California

Cal. Ct. App. 4th Dist., Div. 1CaliforniaD014677
Timeline entries in this matter (1)Open the full record →

Outside the record

Coverage

5 entries · podcast, documentary, book

  • DOCUMENTARY Unusual Suspects 2010

    Unusual Suspects episode on the investigation that identified Peyer.

  • DOCUMENTARY Forensic Files 2004

    Forensic Files episode on the evidence that convicted Officer Craig Peyer.

  • DOCUMENTARY City Confidential 2003

    City Confidential episode on the murder and the CHP officer convicted of it.

  • BOOK Joe Cantlupe and Lisa Petrillo 1991

    The San Diego journalists' book on the case against CHP officer Craig Peyer.

  • PODCAST1 episode on this case

    Going West: True Crime

Full timeline

Lane
Proceeding
Sort

Open ring: MilestoneFilled ring: Verdict

  1. Dec 28 · Death reported — investigation event

    Body of Cara Knott discovered

  2. May 18 · Plea — court event

    Pleads not guilty; trial ordered

    After a preliminary hearing earlier in May, Craig Alan Peyer pleaded not guilty to the murder of Cara Knott at his Superior Court arraignment.

  3. Jan 14 · Trial start — court event

    Jury chosen for the first trial

    A jury of four women and eight men was chosen for Craig Peyer's first murder trial, after the judge refused to move the trial out of San Diego.

  4. Apr 18 · Trial start — court event

    Second trial jury selection begins

  5. Jan 11 · Parole hearing — court event

    Parole denied for 15 years

    At his third parole hearing, the parole board refused to release Craig Peyer and ruled he could not be considered again for 15 years.

What the source labels mean

Follow this case

Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.

Know a podcast, documentary, book or magazine about this case?

Record updated 18 Nov 2026